{"id":"CVE-2026-71500","aliases":["GHSA-rgg9-956j-3378"],"url":"https://o3.security/vulnerability/CVE-2026-71500","summary":"Mareforma: invalidated claims still promote to REPLICATED","details":"## What's wrong\n\n`_maybe_update_replicated_unlocked` never checks `t_invalid`, so a claim that a signed contradiction verdict has marked invalid can still climb to REPLICATED through convergence detection, and it pulls an honest peer up with it.\n\nThree gaps line up:\n\n- The new-claim short-circuit reads only `status` and `asserter_keyid` (`core.py:1339-1352`); an invalidated but still-`open` new claim passes.\n- The candidate-peer SELECT filters `status = 'open'`, `unresolved = 0`, and `transparency_logged = 1` but has no `t_invalid` predicate (`core.py:1390-1410`), so an invalidated existing claim qualifies as a convergence partner.\n- The promotion UPDATE gates only on `status = 'open'` (`core.py:1422-1426`), leaving a TOCTOU window even after the SELECT is fixed.\n\nA signed contradiction verdict is meant to be terminal for the trust ladder: `validate_claim` refuses to promote a `t_invalid` claim to ESTABLISHED, and `record_replication_verdict` already gates its promotion UPDATE on `t_invalid IS NULL`. Convergence promotion is the one path that ignores the verdict. Reproduced at runtime: contradict claim X (t_invalid set, still PRELIMINARY), then assert peer Y sharing X's ESTABLISHED anchor; both X and Y land at REPLICATED, with X's `t_invalid` still set.\n\n## Severity and impact\n\n**High.** A refuted claim re-enters the trust ladder at REPLICATED after its contradiction, and it serves as the corroborating peer that promotes an honest claim. Both outcomes contradict the documented refutation model, and REPLICATED is the input to further validation.\n\n## Location\n\n- `mareforma/db/core.py:1339` new-claim short-circuit checks `status` and `asserter_keyid` but not `t_invalid`\n- `mareforma/db/core.py:1390` candidate-peer SELECT WHERE clause has no `t_invalid IS NULL` predicate\n- `mareforma/db/core.py:1422` promotion UPDATE gates on `status = 'open'` only, reopening the window between SELECT and UPDATE\n\n## Fix direction\n\nTreat `t_invalid` the way the neighboring code already does. Extend the new-claim short-circuit to also read `t_invalid` and return when it is set. Add `AND c.t_invalid IS NULL` to the candidate-peer SELECT. Add `AND t_invalid IS NULL` to the promotion UPDATE's WHERE clause so the row-level lock closes the TOCTOU window, matching the gate `record_replication_verdict` already applies at `core.py:3539`.\n\nDo red/green TDD: add a regression test that fails on `main`, then make it pass.\n\n## Quality bar\n\nSOLID, DRY, KISS. Clean, readable, well-tested code. No new errors, warnings, or test failures; the full suite stays green on all supported Python versions.","published":"2026-11-18T22:52:24.176Z","modified":"2026-11-19T21:01:24.335060540Z","cvss":null,"epss":{"score":0.00118,"percentile":0.01796,"asOf":"2026-11-19"},"cisaKev":null,"exploitsKnown":0,"affectedPackages":[{"ecosystem":"PyPI","name":"mareforma","fixedVersion":"0.3.8"}],"fix":{"url":"https://github.com/mareforma/mareforma/commit/c9d8922132d916e4fd013890cb4e17921e00065e","label":"mareforma/mareforma@c9d8922"},"references":[{"type":"WEB","url":"https://github.com/mareforma/mareforma/releases/tag/v0.3.8"},{"type":"ADVISORY","url":"https://github.com/CVEProject/cvelistV5/tree/main/cves/2026/71xxx/CVE-2026-71500.json"},{"type":"ADVISORY","url":"https://github.com/mareforma/mareforma/security/advisories/GHSA-rgg9-956j-3378"},{"type":"ADVISORY","url":"https://nvd.nist.gov/vuln/detail/CVE-2026-71500"},{"type":"FIX","url":"https://github.com/mareforma/mareforma/commit/c9d8922132d916e4fd013890cb4e17921e00065e"},{"type":"FIX","url":"https://github.com/mareforma/mareforma/pull/58"},{"type":"PACKAGE","url":"https://github.com/mareforma/mareforma"}],"provenance":{"sources":["OSV.dev","FIRST.org (EPSS)"],"lastVerified":"2026-11-19T21:01:24.335060540Z"}}